Homemade Mason Jar Butter
Skip the butter aisle at your local grocer. Instead, I present to you homemade mason jar butter.
Butter is a staple for cooking and baking. Unlike oil-based alternatives, butter can take on the odors and tastes of the area it is stored and it can also spoil after a while. This means we need to be mindful of how we store our butter and what is being stored near our butter. There are simple ways to store butter in your home – freezer, refrigerator, and countertop.
How to Store Butter
You probably know someone who stores butter on their counter. You’d also be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn’t store butter in their refrigerator. Which storage option is best – counter or fridge? Read on for butter storage tips!
Warm on the counter for easy spreading
One downside to using real butter is that it does not spread well when it is cold. This is a real issue when trying to butter a slice of bread, a muffin, or a roll, just to name a few items. I can still hear my husband throwing a fit when trying to butter bread to make a grilled cheese sandwich.
To solve this issue, try blending the butter with olive oil. Keep in mind, though, this will change the texture and the taste, so I recommend starting with a small portion for everyone to try rather than throwing it all away because no one likes it.
Another alternative is to store your butter outside of the refrigerator. I recommend storing it in a covered butter dish if electing to use this alternative, especially if you have pets. No one likes dog or cat hairs in their butter.
Butter is safe to leave at room temperature for up to a few days, but this can leave the butter tasting rancid if left out too long. I recommend leaving out just enough to last a day or two for the best results.
When storing butter on the counter, I also recommend salted butter. The salt helps to fight microbes allowing the butter to stay fresh longer than unsalted butter would at room temperature. For room-temperature applications, salted is also better-tasting making it the most convenient option.
When storing butter at room temperature you want to put it in an air-tight container. Ideally, this should be a butter dish or even better a butter bell where the butter is suspended in a dish of cold water that helps keep it slightly cooler and creates an air-tight seal that prevents oxygen and bacteria from reaching your butter to spoil it.
Do not store butter on your counter during the hot summer days. While room temperature is safe for butter, when the kitchen starts to creep into the 70s it is no longer a good idea to store butter on the counter. Instead, keep it in the refrigerator and pull it out to warm before use. In a warm kitchen on a hot summer day, this will not take long. One option is to pull it out the night before to use for breakfast and then return it to the refrigerator after breakfast.
Storing butter in the refrigerator
Often when storing the butter in the refrigerator, we simply toss it into the little container located on the inside of the fridge. While this is fine for butter you are going to use quickly, it is not ideal for butter that may be sitting for a few weeks. The door of the refrigerator warms up with every opening. This can lead to the melting and cooling of the butter changing the overall consistency and flavor over time.
Butter can easily absorb the flavor of other foods in your refrigerator. This can make the butter taste weird and even spoil rather quickly. For the best results, any butter you are storing in the refrigerator beyond the open box should be sealed in another air-tight container and placed at the back of the main compartment of your refrigerator. This will help keep the temperature steady and lockout flavors and odors that can ruin your butter.
How to freeze butter for long term storage
The best way to store butter when you find a deal on it is to freeze it. Frozen butter adds about 6 months to the use by date for butter. This allows you to stock up on large amounts of butter when a sale comes around during the holidays and store it for use later. For families that go through a lot of butter or do a lot of baking, buying butter in large quantities during sales is a great way to save money and never have to worry about running out when you need it most.
To freeze butter for storage, you want to leave it in its original wax paper and cardboard box. This combination will help prevent it from getting freezer burn or taking on unwanted flavors from your freezer. As an added layer of protection, you should place your butter in a freezer bag and remove all of the air. If you plan to freeze in your deep freezer for longer than 6 months, you should consider using a vacuum sealer and vacuum sealer bags to get the best air-tight seal for long-term storage.
How to store ghee
Ghee is clarified butter you can buy in a jar near your other shelf-stable oils. As you can likely guess, these jars are safe at room temperature while sealed. Once opened, ghee can be stored on the counter for up to 3 months or in the refrigerator for up to a year allowing you plenty of time to use a standard jar of ghee.
Are you ready to learn how to make your very own homemade mason jar butter? It’s a fast and easy recipe that everyone is going to love!
Ingredients needed to make butter in a mason jar
- 1 cup Heavy Whipping Cream
- ½ teaspoon of Salt, optional
- 2-3 tablespoons of Ice-Cold Water
- 1 pint Mason Jar, with lid
How to Make Homemade Mason Jar Butter
This recipe is super easy to make without a lot of steps!
Start by placing the cream into the mason jar and then tightly screwing the lid shut.
Then you will need to shake the jar vigorously. You will hear the jar/cream make a gentle thudding sound as the cream begins to thicken.
After about 6 minutes or so it will thicken up considerably.
Continue to shake and then at the 10–12-minute mark, you will notice that the jar is not making the sound anymore. This means it is at the whipped cream stage-yay!
You’re still not done so keep shaking for another 4-5 minutes, and you will hear the jar making a sloshing sound. Also, you will notice that the fat has separated from the milk and it looks like a cuddled mess. This is how it is supposed to look, so don’t worry!
After this point, you need to add 2 tablespoons of ice-cold water and then keep shaking for another 3-4 minutes. You will see all the fat had come together into a ball.
Now strain the liquid. pro tip—Do not discard the liquid because that is buttermilk! You can use this in recipes that call for buttermilk.
Now take your butter ball and rinse it in cold water to get rid of any buttermilk residue. This will help to prolong the life of the butter.
Decide if you want salted butter or not. If you do then all you have to do is add half a teaspoon of salt to the butter and mix it well with a fork.
Finally, shape into a round ball or a log and serve immediately with freshly toasted bread or cover tightly and refrigerate for later.
Tips for Making Mason Jar Butter
It took about 17 to 18 minutes for me to complete the butter-making process. But if you shake very vigorously, it will be done sooner.
What size mason jar you choose also determines how much time you will need to make butter. Simple math, the bigger the jar the longer it will take.
Make sure to fill only half of your mason jar. If you overfill, there won’t be any space for the cream to whip itself. It needs the air in the jar to whip itself.
Love this simple recipe homemade mason jar butter recipe? We have more!
More Easy Recipes to Try
Homemade Mason Jar Butter
This simple butter recipe makes about 1/2 cup of butter.
Ingredients
- 1 cup Heavy Whipping Cream
- ½ teaspoon of Salt, optional
- 2-3 tablespoons of Ice-Cold Water
- 1 pint Mason Jar, with lid
Instructions
Place the cream in the mason jar and tightly screw the lid.
Shake the jar vigorously. It will make a gentle thudding sound as the cream begins to thicken.
After 6 minutes it will thicken up considerably.
Keep shaking and at the 10–12-minute mark, you will notice that the jar is not making any sound. That means it is at the whipped cream stage.
Keep shaking for another 4-5 minutes, and you will hear the jar making a sloshing sound. You will notice that the fat das separated from the milk and it looks like a cuddled mess.
Add 2 tablespoons of ice-cold water and keep shaking for another 3-4 minutes and you will see all the fat had come together into a ball.
Strain the liquid. Do not discard the liquid. That is buttermilk. Use in recipes that call for buttermilk.
Rinse the butterball in cold water to get rid of any buttermilk residue. This helps prolong the life of the butter.
If you want salted butter, add half a teaspoon of salt to the butter and mix it well with a fork.
Shape into a round ball or a log and serve immediately with freshly toasted bread or cover tightly and refrigerate for later.